A few days before the November 4th election, I took a photo with an organizer while doorknocking to get the vote out. In that photo, the organizer and I pointed at one another (after, it has often been remarked, an awkward moment of set-up). A local news station ran a story that the pointing of our fingers constituted gang signs, that the photo undermined the morale of the officers in the Minneapolis Police Department, and that participating in the photo constituted poor judgment on my part. The head of the Minneapolis Police Federation — the union that represents Minneapolis police officers — made a comment publicly to that effect. He said, “She should know better” and asked, “Is she on the side of the cops or the gangs?”

As one of the two people pointing in the photo, I’ve tried to understand what the head of the police union thinks I should do, or not do. There seem to be four options.

First, maybe the head of the police union would like me to stop pointing altogether for the safety of the community. If that were truly his concern, that my pointing constitutes gang activity, then his outrage would have been sparked long, long ago. Because as the internet has documented in great detail, I point. I point a lot. Lots of people point. The President. Bill Clinton. Stephen Colbert. Babies. It is the earliest form of human communication.* I’m not going to stop pointing.

That option doesn’t make sense.

Second, maybe the head of the police union wants me to refrain from being in the presence of people whose criminal history I don’t know. In other words, maybe the head of the police union doesn’t want me interacting with the public. When I meet people, I don’t know if they have ever been arrested for or convicted of embezzlement, or domestic assault, or shoplifting, or murder, or burglary, or driving under the influence, gun or drug possession, or too many parking tickets. I have no way of knowing, nor do I ask. Frankly, if I did know that someone had a criminal past, it wouldn’t prevent me from talking with that person. It certainly wouldn’t prevent me from working on a Get Out The Vote drive with that person. That’s the kind of mayor Minneapolis chose.

That option doesn’t make sense, either.

The third option may be that the head of the police union doesn’t want me standing next to young African American men. One frightening implication of the KSTP story and police union President Delmonico’s support of that story is their implicit assumption that I should use stereotypes to assess with whom I should or should not meet or stand or talk. As The Onion once satirically wrote, “Stereotypes are a real time saver.” It is not a good basis for decision-making, however. It blunts the humanity of the person making the judgment and creates unnecessary separation between two people in a world where more, rather than less, human connection is needed for us to move forward as a community.

This is yet one more option that doesn’t make sense.

Which leaves one final option. It could be that the head of the police union wants me to stop working to raise the standards of police culture and accountability. It could be that he objects to the community policing and relationship-building measures that I am acting on, and attempted to use this non-story to discredit this work.

I share the public’s speculation that this is the real option.

If that is the case, he has failed on two levels. First, the people of the internet have called out this story over and over with outrage and humor, shining the light of day on the ridiculous premise on which it was based.

Second, and more significantly, I am undaunted in my commitment to making sure that police–community relationships are as strong as they can be. I am undaunted in my desire to support and develop police officers who serve respectfully and collaboratively every day to keep people safe and make all our neighborhoods stronger. I am undaunted in my plans to increase accountability for consistent bad actors in the police department.

Let me be clear on this final point. There is a critical difference between our good officers who have a bad day on the job, and officers, however few, who have a standing habit of mistreatment and poor judgment when relating to the public, particularly people of color. I am as concerned with the negative effects of this conduct on the police department as a whole as I am with its effects on our community. I am convinced that we can change it, even if it takes years.

If the fourth option is correct, my commitment to this work means that the head of the police union or other detractors will pitch more stories that attempt to defame that work and its leaders to various media outlets. So be it. I know the charge that I have been given by the people of Minneapolis and by my own conscience. I will continue to follow that charge.

*UPDATE: My apologies to The Daily Show, whose research was instrumental to my understanding of pointerology. “The President. Bill Clinton. Stephen Colbert. Babies. It is the earliest form of human communication.”

This entry was posted in Uncategorized by Mayor Betsy Hodges. Bookmark the permalink.

About Mayor Betsy Hodges

I am the 47th mayor of Minneapolis, Minnesota, sworn in on January 2, 2014. Prior to becoming mayor, I served on the Minneapolis City Council for eight years as the representative of Ward 13. On the Council, I served as chair of the Ways and Means/Budget Committee. Before running for public office, I was an organizer, working for TakeAction Minnesota and the Minnesota Justice Foundation. I also helped found a program in Albuquerque, New Mexico to get HIV-positive women the help and resources that they needed. My husband, Gary Cunningham, President and CEO of the Metropolitan Economic Development Association (MEDA) and a member of the Metropolitan Council. We have two children, four grandchildren, a dog and a slightly neurotic cat. In my spare time, I work on staying physically fit, writing, reading poetry and enjoying seasonal viewings of “Die Hard,” my favorite movie. I have an extensive collection of Wonder Woman memorabilia, and am an occasional karaoke singer with a limited range.

241 thoughts on “#pointergate

  1. Heartening response, Madame Mayor. I hope you leave this post up for posterity, and I hope we see your name coming up on a national level some day.

  2. Mayor Hodges, your response to this faux scandal gives me so much renewed hope in public servants, and public service. Keep pressing forward with the important work that you are doing.

  3. I had to comment on this absurd accusation allegedly made by the police department and then into a sensational news story by KTSP. Any one, with a brain, knows that merely pointing a finger at someone is not a gang sign (especially the police), unless it is one that has infiltrated every country in the world.
    It appears evident to me that this is either a slanderous attempt at revenge by the police or an irresponsible “mistake” by an questionable reporter. Could there, also, be a hint of racism involved? In any event, the station should issue an apology (reporting the facts) for insinuating that Mayor Hodges and Jay Knolls were exchanging gang signs in a picture taken while canvassing for votes. How stupid would they both have to be?! Nowadays, it never ceases to amaze me how biased and incompetent the media has become, as well as, how vicious and out-of-control law enforcement can be.

    This mayor appears to a courageous, forthright and honest politician who is attempting to make Minneapolis a safe place to live and that the citizens are lucky to have her.

    • Pat P, Jay Kolls is the reporter, he has a criminal record for DWI as well. The owner of the station, Hubbard refused to apologize or retract story.

  4. Pingback: What We’re Reading: Citizen: An American Lyric | Hazel & Wren

  5. This is a great story. Thank you for sharing. There is serious social illness in society that is spreading to the basic foundation of the Constitution, and which undermines the fundamental rights that are guaranteed under that document. Debates, albeit accompanied by finger pointing, is a part of freedom of expression and part of human interaction in the heat of the moment. Such activity should be as welcome now as it was in 1776.

  6. Pingback: Pointergate: ‘Digital’ Revolution Erupts After KSTP Report | c2meworld.com

  7. Mayor hodges is “ride or die”. How’s that for gang analogies? Thank you for you cogent analysis of a “whack” comment by the police chief. Your coment elevated the discussion.

  8. Pingback: Ferguson Unrest Catches Fire in Minneapolis | Imagining If

  9. Pingback: Ferguson Unrest Catches Fire in Minneapolis

  10. Pingback: Ferguson Unrest Catches Fire in Minneapolis | Omaha Sun Times

  11. Pingback: Ferguson Unrest Catches Fire in Minneapolis » NY G Spot

  12. Pingback: How a big story gets broken (accidentally) | The Rhino and Compass

  13. Pingback: Ferguson Unrest Catches Fire in Minneapolis | Political Ration

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s